Why Dating Apps Leave You Feeling Lonely and How to Find Real Connection
Lessons from my conversation with Pieter Niemann, author of Swiping for Something Real.
FINDING LOVE
Fernanda
11/16/202610 min read


Have you ever swiped on dating apps for an hour and felt lonelier than when you started? I hear this from so many daters in the Filled Cups community, and I have felt a version of it myself. There are the tired thumbs, the hopeful little jolt of a new match, and then the sinking feeling when a conversation fizzles out.
I sat down with Pieter Niemann, who was trained in mental health in South Africa and now lives in Switzerland, to talk about all of it on the Connectedness Podcast. He is the author of Swiping for Something Real: Reflective Practices for Queer Intimacy, Loneliness, and Love, and this post gathers the ideas from our conversation that I keep coming back to. I hope they feel as warm and useful to you as they did to me.
Key Takeaways
Dating apps work like catalogs. A profile shows a small fraction of a person, so a quick swipe can only judge that small fraction.
Looking for a title (boyfriend, girlfriend, husband, wife) before you know the person can leave you disappointed.
Healthy love brings together two whole people who each keep their own friends, hobbies, and community.
Ghosting hurts, and the person who gets ghosted often carries responsibility that belongs to the person who left.
Emotional safety feels easy, unforced, and free of guilt or games.
A helpful question to ask before you open an app: what am I needing right now?
If dating has you burned out, reconnect with your friends and community and keep living your life.
Who Is Pieter Niemann, and Why Did He Write Swiping for Something Real?
Pieter told me the book grew out of several things happening at once. He had lost his job the year before and was home with time to write, and a few friends going through similar relationship struggles kept asking him similar questions. He figured that if so many people in his own circle wanted these answers, there had to be a greater need, so he gathered his thoughts and their conversations into the book.
I related right away, because I lost my job last year too. It moved me to hear how a hard season turned into a creative project that now helps other people feel less alone.
Pieter wrote from a queer perspective, and he was clear that the book is for everyone. In his words, connection is connection, and what changes between communities is mostly how people practice it. Everything we talked about felt relevant to me, and I believe it will feel relevant to you whatever your orientation or relationship status.
Why Do Dating Apps Leave Us Feeling Lonely?
Pieter explained that once you understand the technology, you see that dating apps are designed as catalogs. Think about ordering clothes from an online store, where the photos only show a small piece of what actually arrives at your door. Profiles work the same way, so if you met that same person at a party, you might choose differently.
I have said this so many times in Filled Cups that I feel like a broken record. If the person you swiped left on turned out to be charming, interesting, and kind at a party, would you have walked away from them? Pieter is not against apps, and he told me so right away. I will admit I am a little bit anti-app myself, but I understand that apps are the main way many people meet, so the real question is how to use them better.
He also described the quick yes or no rhythm of swiping, which feels a lot like an interview. We start to believe that knowing someone's demographic details will lead us to fall in love, yet those details tell us very little about who the person is. When we also arrive hoping to meet Mr. or Mrs. Perfect, we put the title before the person, and that sets us up for disappointment.
What Does "Real" Connection Mean in Dating?
For Pieter, real means knowing people on a deeper level than their name and demographics. Our society has become very individualistic and disconnected, and we often skip the part where we get to know who someone actually is. The title of his book points toward getting to know people better, even while you swipe.
One of his friends always says, "I'm looking for a boyfriend." Pieter's gentle response is that this friend is looking for a title first and a connection second. A checklist can tell you whether someone fulfills certain categories, but it cannot tell you whether that person meets your emotional, physical, and cognitive needs, or whether you meet theirs. Pieter was clear that wanting certain things is perfectly fine. The invitation is to ask yourself whether you are meeting a person or checking boxes.
Why Should You Be a Whole Person Before You Date?
This was the heart of our conversation for me. Pieter dislikes the language of "my other half," because it means walking into a relationship expecting to be completed or saved. If you arrive that way, you may never know whether the person is there for you or whether you are holding on to what they complete in you.
His biggest argument in the book is to have your own community, friends, hobbies, and events, and then to invite someone into your space as they invite you into theirs. He described love as two whole lives coming together to make a bigger, more complete picture. I love that image so much.
I shared a true story with him. A woman in my social circle disappeared for four years after she fell in love, and when the relationship ended, she returned to her friends. I do not judge her, because many of us have done something similar, but her story shows why keeping your identity and your circle while you explore a new relationship matters.
Pieter shared that research on community points in the same direction. The more integrated we are in our communities, the better we tend to handle breakups and other upsetting news, because we keep both our own identity and our connected identity with friends and family. Breakups still hurt, and the identity shift still happens, yet you get to bounce back with people who love you around you.
How Does Ghosting Affect Our Self-Worth?
Pieter was honest that when you put yourself on a catalog, you will sometimes be treated as an option, and that comes with the territory of the apps. Even so, ghosting still hurts. Being ghosted can make a person feel not enough, broken, or beyond acceptance. In the gay community, he sees it happen often, with people judging a profile by the body, the photos, or a missing keyword. You might chat for three or four hours, have a wonderful conversation, and then the person is gone.
What stayed with me most is what he said about responsibility. The person who is ghosted tends to take on the job of figuring out what went wrong, when the other person was clearly not interested or did not communicate. Pieter put it as taking off some responsibility that you cannot carry on your own.
I have been ghosted by friends, which was really painful, and years ago by someone I was seeing romantically. I am happily married now, and with that distance the romantic one feels almost absurd. A short text would have been enough, and being left in limbo is the part that stings. Pieter shared that people often ghost because they fear being seen as the villain or breaking someone's heart, but that fear does not remove the responsibility to say something honest and kind.
Why Do Communication Rhythms Matter in Dating?
Pieter is neurodivergent himself, and he told me he connects with people in a very specific way. Sometimes he can go two weeks without speaking to a friend and feel completely fine, because his relationship stays the same in his mind, while his friend may feel differently. People connect in many different ways depending on introversion, extroversion, neurodivergence, and neurotypicality.
Hearing that helped me extend more grace. I have many neurodivergent people in my life, and I want to remember that silence can mean very different things to different people. A simple conversation about rhythm, such as how often each of you likes to check in, could save a lot of hurt.
Where Do Unrealistic Dating Expectations Come From?
Pieter pointed to Disney and the movies many of us grew up with, which taught us that we are only complete with a partner. If you absorb that message, hearing "this is not working" can feel like proof that you are not good enough for one person to choose. That fear of not being chosen or not being perfect shows up everywhere, in every community. I would add social media to the list today, since so much more now shapes our picture of romance.
Pieter also reminded me that people are dynamic. When you meet someone, you put your best foot forward and play down certain things, and that rarely comes from dishonesty. It comes from wanting to be chosen. Down the road, the person changes a little, and so do you. I shared a quote I once read about relationships being like prisms, where different angles reveal different sides of your partner, because none of us is our best self all the time.
How Do You Build Emotional Intimacy With Someone New?
Pieter gave me two answers: authenticity and participation. Authenticity means knowing yourself well enough to feel comfortable showing who you are, which is hard when life has taught us to hide parts of ourselves to stay safe. Participation means taking an active part in forming the connection, whether it becomes romantic, a friendship, or nothing more. Not everyone you meet will become your best friend or your partner, and the more you practice connecting, the easier it gets.
He shared a story I loved about a friend in Cape Town who has a rule that wherever she goes, she leaves with at least one new person's contact details and meets up with them later. Pieter was so inspired that he told his partner he would do the same that night. It did not always lead somewhere, but he was learning to connect on purpose, and I loved it so much that I am planning to borrow the idea.
We also talked about readiness. For Pieter, readiness is the willingness to connect with a person and with the potential consequences, because connecting with someone now means you might develop into something and need to be there later. He has jumped from one relationship straight into the next himself and discovered he was not ready, so he encourages us to be honest about where we are before we begin again.
How Can You Tell If Someone Is Emotionally Safe?
Pieter said this is a very individual question, but a safe person does not pressure you, force you, or make you question yourself. Safe connection tends to feel easy, uncomplicated, and unforced. He gave a simple example of someone asking, "Do you want to hang out tonight?" and a yes or a no being the end of it, with no games and no guilt.
Unfortunately, many of us have been trained by movies to call that kind of relationship boring, because passion and grand airport scenes are supposed to be what true love looks like. For Pieter, true love is being allowed to exist in your space as you are. I think this is a beautiful reminder, and it echoes something I say often on the podcast about choosing people who choose you.
One Question to Ask Before You Open a Dating App
Pieter's book is written so readers can pause and ask themselves questions about their own lives. The practice he offered was to ask yourself what you are needing right now that has you going onto these apps at this moment, and then to really think about your answer.
It is easy to say "I'm lonely," but he encouraged us to look deeper. Do I need more time with my friends, or am I taking space for myself? Which emotions are stirring in me that make me feel I need to connect with somebody right now? One honest question can hold a lot of information, and I realized it works just as well for doomscrolling or browsing social media.
What If You Feel Burned Out and Hopeless About Dating?
Pieter's answer was to connect with your friends and your community. If you do not have a community, start creating one, and start living your life. He asked whether we are looking for a connection or for a title, and he reminded us that when we stop forcing things, plans tend to happen. You might even meet the person of your dreams just by existing, living, and being who you are meant to be.
His hope for readers is that they close the book, take a deep breath, and start connecting, whether that connection is romantic or not. If you are in the Charlotte area and want to meet people in person, I would love to see you at a Filled Cups event, where friends and singles gather to build real connections.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do dating apps make me feel lonely? Pieter Niemann explains that dating apps work like catalogs, where quick yes or no decisions are based on a small piece of who someone is. Knowing a person's demographic details is very different from knowing the person, and that gap can leave us feeling disconnected even when matches keep coming.
Is it okay to have a list of what I want in a partner? Yes, wanting certain things is fine. Pieter suggests checking whether you are meeting the person in front of you or only checking boxes, since a checklist covers just one small part of who someone is.
How do I cope with being ghosted? Remember that ghosting is still painful, and that the responsibility for communicating belongs to the person who left. You do not have to carry the work of figuring out what you did wrong, especially when the other person simply chose not to talk.
How do I know if someone is emotionally safe? A safe person does not pressure you, force you, or make you question yourself. Connection with them feels easy and unforced, and you are allowed to be yourself without second guessing whether they want to be with you.
Is Swiping for Something Real only for queer readers? No. Pieter wrote the book from a queer perspective, and he believes connection is connection, so the reflections on attachment, expectations, identity, and intimacy apply to anyone who wants to be known by someone they love.
What should I do if I feel burned out by dating? Pieter recommends connecting with friends and community, creating a community if you do not have one, and living your life fully. Many people find that real connection shows up when they stop forcing it.
Your One Small Step This Week
If this conversation stirred something in you, I hope you will take one small step this week. Maybe you can journal about what you are really looking for, or tell someone how you feel instead of waiting for them to guess. Both are ways of choosing connection, and both are ways of choosing people who choose you.
You can listen to my full conversation with Pieter on the Connectedness Podcast: [EPISODE LINK]. You can also find Pieter's book, Swiping for Something Real: Reflective Practices for Queer Intimacy, Loneliness, and Love, here: [BOOK LINK].
Connecting individuals through meaningful relationships and valuable resources.
connect
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for valuable insights and event news.
© 2026. Filled Cups.® All Rights Reserved.
Bring FC to your city
INSPIRATION
