Why Dating Apps Can Leave You Feeling Lonely | Pieter Niemann
Fernanda: Hi friends, welcome back to the Connectedness podcast. I'm Fernanda, and today we're talking about something many of us carry in our pockets every day: dating apps and the hope, the tired thumbs, and the occasional heartbreak that comes with them. If you've ever swiped for an hour and felt lonelier than when you started, this conversation is for you.
My guest is Pieter Niemann, who trained in mental health in South Africa and is now based in Switzerland. Pieter is the author of Swiping for Something Real: Reflective Practices for Queer Intimacy, Loneliness, and Love. He wrote the book from a queer perspective, and the questions it raises about attachment, expectations, identity, and intimacy speak to anyone who has ever wanted to be known by someone they love.
Not long ago, I shared an episode inspired by The Company We Keep, where we talked about emotional safety, ghosting, and choosing people who choose you. Today, I'd like to carry that into romance and ask what real intimacy takes when there's always one more profile to scroll. Pieter, thank you for joining the show.
Pieter Niemann: Yeah, thank you very much for the invitation.
Fernanda: Yes, thank you. So, I guess let's get started with your history. What led you to write this book? Was there a moment, a pattern, or a personal experience that made you feel it needed to exist?
Pieter Niemann: Actually, all of those. So, last year I lost my job and I was at home, and I decided, "Okay, well, I enjoy writing, so why not write something?"
At the same time, I had a few friends that were going through similar relational issues, which they all continued asking me similar questions about. That led me to think, "Okay, well, if in my personal sphere there are so many requests for these answers, there must be a greater need for them." And that led me to actually summarize some of the thoughts that I had and discussions I had with them and put it into the book.
Fernanda: Oh, how cool. And I'm sorry you lost your job. Trust me, I can relate because I also lost my job last year. But the good news is it led you to a creative pursuit that's actually going to help people, right?
Pieter Niemann: Yes.
Fernanda: And so your title, it promises something real when it comes to romantic connection. What does that mean for you?
Pieter Niemann: So for me, "real" is—today's society has become very individualistic and very disconnected. We think that when we connect to people, it's just about knowing their name and their demographics.
We often fail to actually know who they are on a semi-deeper level. It doesn't have to be romantic or intimate, but we tend to not understand people and know people for who they are. That's what this title actually refers to. It's being able to swipe or getting to know people in a way that you actually get to know them on a better level.
Fernanda: Yeah. And I'll just take that from talking to daters in Filled Cups, my connections brand, where I get to hear a lot of grievances about the dating apps. One of the biggest grievances I see or hear is that people are swiping and making very quick judgment calls on somebody based on their appearance or maybe a few factors that might be the first thing on the profile.
It just blows my mind. I feel like a broken record because I've talked about this a lot, and I'm like, if you're at a party and you meet that exact person that you swiped left on, and that person turns out to be really cool, charming, interesting, and treats you very well, would you have swiped left on that person? Right? Like, I think I'm preaching to the choir.
Pieter Niemann: I think what a lot of people miss—and let me just say from the get-go, I'm not anti-apps at all. I'm not saying that they're evil or anything. But once you understand the technology behind apps, you would understand that these apps are actually designed only as catalogs.
Just as you would buy clothing from an online store, you won't always get exactly what you saw in the pictures, because the pictures are just a small fraction of the representation of what is actually available. So, yes, if you meet somebody in real life, you might have chosen differently.
Fernanda: Right. I like the comparison to a catalog. I heard somebody say—I think it's another dating-coach-type personality on social media—she talks about shopping, like "shop smarter" when you're shopping on the apps. How can you shop smarter? So why do you think dating apps can leave people feeling lonelier even if the messages or the matches keep coming?
Pieter Niemann: Well, what often happens is you have this very quick yes-no round where it's very interview-like, and people think that knowing, like I said, the demographic details of a person is actually going to lead them to fall in love and meet this amazing person. But it's actually just knowing their demographic details.
People, when they go online, often go online with the idea of, "I'm going to meet Mr. or Mrs. Perfect. I'm going to meet my boyfriend or my girlfriend." At the end of the day, if you put the title before the person, then you are going to leave yourself disappointed.
Fernanda: Yes. So the title and the demographic—thank you, you're bringing so much new stuff to the podcast—with the demographic, you just find out their demographic information. You're not truly getting to know them.
Pieter Niemann: No.
Fernanda: And I think that's a very powerful reframe for daters. So when somebody is opening an app, what do you think they're really hoping to find in a partner?
Pieter Niemann: I think a lot of people imagine that they know. It's very rare that people who think they know actually know, because it becomes a system of, "If I have a very stringent list, is this list actually realistic? Is this list actually achievable?"
I'm not saying that wanting certain things is wrong. I'm more arguing that if you are meeting people with a categorization or a list in mind, are you actually then meeting the person or are you just doing a check exercise?
Fernanda: Yes, checking the boxes.
Pieter Niemann: Yeah. So then are you actually hoping to meet somebody you could love, or are you just fulfilling a list?
Fernanda: Right, someone that you could love, that could love you, and that could be a good companion to you that could help fulfill your emotional needs. And by the way, I think it's pretty hard to tell when you meet somebody whether someone will be the right person who meets your emotional needs, right? But that's why people date and become involved in relationships. It's because we've got to find that out. It takes a little bit of time, right?
Pieter Niemann: Yes. The biggest argument I make is the argument of community. A lot of people approach relationships as, "I'm looking for somebody to fulfill me. I'm looking for my other half." And I hate that language because it means that you are coming into a relationship not as a real, fully realized person.
You're going there as a person expecting to be saved, expecting to be completed, expecting to be given friendships or community or financial support, whatever those reasons are. If you go into a relationship with those things, then you're actually never going to know if this person is really going to be there for you, or if you are just sticking to them because of the things that they're completing in you.
That's why my biggest argument that I make in the book is to have a community, have friends, have your own life, be a whole, and invite somebody into your space and into your community as they do for you.
Fernanda: Okay, as they do for you. So in your vision, both people would have their own communities and be invited to each other's communities, is what you're saying?
Pieter Niemann: Yes. Be a complete person. Have interests, have hobbies, have friends, have events that you do, have stuff in your life. And the other person should have that too. Because it's never about taking two halves and making a whole. It is about integrating two wholes and just making a bigger, more complete picture of two people.
Fernanda: I love this. And if we take it one step further, one thing I see in my social circle sometimes—not always—is somebody falls in love and they completely disappear. And this is a true story; I won't mention any names or anything, but I actually met a woman again after she had disappeared for four years, and she's back in the social circle.
I was like, "Oh, yeah, what happened? Are you okay? Where did you go?" And she had fallen in love, and I guess that became her whole life, like the new relationship. Then unfortunately, the relationship didn't work out after a few years, so now she's back in the social circle.
Pieter Niemann: Yeah.
Fernanda: And I know people do that, and it is what it is kind of thing, but I don't recommend it because being a whole person means keeping your identity in your circle even when you are in love and exploring a new relationship.
Pieter Niemann: Even psychology research says that the more integrated we are in communities, the better we handle breakups or loss or these types of traumatic or upsetting news or incidents. If you're integrated, you are able to maintain yourself because you maintain not only your own identity, but your connected identity with your friends and family. So you maintain this individual structure, and you don't have to rebuild anything because you've never actually lost it.
Fernanda: Yeah, and I can see how that would be a lot. Breakups are hard no matter what, right? But if you are going through a breakup with the support of your community, it's likely to help you heal faster, or at least help you feel like you still have other parts in your life—people who love you, even if they're not the romantic partner that just ended the relationship, right?
Pieter Niemann: Yes. It really gives you that chance to say, "I don't have to ask, 'I don't know who I am,' because I've never let go of that." So yes, that whole identity shift is still going to happen because you've lost somebody—in the case of your friend, they spent four years building this identity—but if they were more connected with their network, they would have still retained more of a core identity, which would have allowed them to bounce back quicker.
Fernanda: Yes, absolutely. Okay, so if we're going back to the apps—and I know you're not anti-app. I'm a little bit anti-app, I'll be honest, but I understand that that's the main method that people use. So for me, it's like, okay, it's the way of the world, so how can you be better on the apps, right? When it comes to the apps, what happens to us emotionally when we start to feel like we're just options for each other? Can you talk about ghosting and how it affects our sense of self-worth?
Pieter Niemann: We are always just options, and if you put yourself on a catalog, that's all you are. You are a picture, your profile on a catalog, and unfortunately, if you put yourself out there, that is something you need to accept.
But it doesn't mean that ghosting doesn't hurt, because ghosting is still painful. What ghosting typically does to a person that's being ghosted is it actually sometimes makes them feel like they are not enough, they are broken, they are beyond acceptance.
In the gay community specifically, it happens so often that people prejudge a profile just because of the way the body looks, or the way the photos are taken, or a keyword that's missing in the profile. You might have chatted for three or four hours having a great conversation, and then suddenly they're gone, and you're left thinking, "Okay, what did I do?"
The problem is always that the person who is being ghosted often takes that energy upon themselves, or the responsibility upon themselves, and they carry that responsibility to sort it out instead of thinking, "Okay, well, this person was clearly not interested. What else could I do if we do not have a conversation about why it doesn't work?" Just taking off some of that responsibility that you can't carry on your own.
Fernanda: Right. I love that. And I feel like that can apply to any kind of ghosting, not just on the apps, but in normal relationships too, like friendships. I hear ghosting is more and more common, unfortunately, and I personally have been ghosted by a couple of friends, so it was really painful.
I think back years ago, I remember I did get—I'm smiling because it's not painful anymore—but I did get ghosted by someone I was seeing romantically. Nowadays, with years of distance between that situation and now, it just feels very absurd. Like, couldn't he have just sent me a text or something and said, "Hey, this isn't going to work," and just move on? You know what I mean?
Pieter Niemann: Because it leaves a person wondering, "Okay, is this temporary? What's happening?" It just leaves a person in limbo. And the other person does not see that they carry a lot of this responsibility—that they actually needed to do the adult thing and say, "Listen, hold on. This is not going how we planned. Let's call it a break. I'm not interested anymore." Whatever the reason, they just need to communicate that.
Fernanda: Right. Thank you for that. And I'm pretty happily married now, and my relationship is fairly secure, so I think it's easy for me to talk about those ghosting experiences so far in the past.
Pieter Niemann: Yeah.
Fernanda: Because I've thankfully been in a place now where I know what it's like to feel truly loved and fully seen by your romantic partner, you know what I mean?
Pieter Niemann: No, I just wanted to add, and that's not something you just see in two or three days. It takes time.
Fernanda: Yes, it does take time. But thanks for sharing that. If we could have our way, ghosting wouldn't be a thing, right? People would have mature conversations—even if it's a text message, which is not ideal—or breakup conversations or a phone call. Any kind of situation like that would be better than ghosting.
Pieter Niemann: Oh, definitely. I think a lot of people are just frightened of either being seen as the villain or having to break somebody's heart, or they just don't want to deal with the drama or potential drama. So there are a lot of reasons why a person can not take that responsibility, but it doesn't take away the responsibility that they actually have to do it.
Fernanda: Right, I do agree. Okay, well, in your book, it sounds like you talk about attachment styles, right? How do attachment styles show up in early dating, like texting rhythms and waiting for a reply, or deciding whether to be vulnerable?
Pieter Niemann: I don't specifically go into attachment styles, but—
Fernanda: Oh, I'm sorry.
Pieter Niemann: No, no, it's fine! I do speak about people's rhythms in communication because as a neurodivergent person myself, I have a very specific way of connecting to people, and I do often see the different ways in which we communicate.
For a person that is struggling to connect to people, they're obviously going to continue a discussion. And for me, "out of sight, out of mind." Actually, sometimes when I don't speak to a friend for two weeks, I'm actually okay with it. My friend is not, but my relationship stays the same. So there's a variety of different ways that people connect to other people depending on their introversion or extroversion, or their neurodiversity or neurotypicalness.
Fernanda: Yeah, that's a really interesting point you're bringing up because I do have a lot of neurodivergent people in my life, and I actually had somebody come on the podcast a few months ago who is an ADHD coach, and she has ADHD, and we talked about the impact of ADHD on relationships.
Pieter Niemann: Mhm.
Fernanda: But she didn't really mention the piece that you just mentioned about, if you go two weeks without contacting someone, to you the relationship is fine, but maybe to your friend it might not be fine. I think that's a really important one to try to remember and give grace to our neurodivergent folks, and so I'm going to try to remember that from now on, too. We actually talked more about rejection sensitivity in that episode, which is a real thing for a lot of people.
Pieter Niemann: Yes. That's also another huge topic that I think a lot of people need to actually go into, because—and this is again not specific to the neurodivergent population or the gay or the straight community, it's everywhere—people are so afraid of not being chosen, not being perfect, not being "the one."
Because if I think about how I grew up, Disney and all these movies said that you can only be perfect or you can only be a complete person if you have a partner. So if I am told, "Listen, this X, Y, and Z is not working, we need to stop seeing each other," I'm going to most likely take that as a personal criticism of my being, because I'm not good enough for one person to choose me.
Fernanda: Yes, so the perfectionism isn't just about ourselves, it's us in the context of relationships.
Pieter Niemann: Yes.
Fernanda: Yeah, I see that. Thank you for bringing that up. What about expectations that people carry into dating that quietly set them up for disappointment? Where do those even come from, or where do you think they come from usually?
Pieter Niemann: Yeah, so we had this conversation earlier: people going into relationships looking for a boyfriend or a girlfriend or a husband or a wife. I have a very specific friend, and they always say, "I'm looking for a boyfriend." And I'm like, "Okay, so you're looking for a title and not a person. You're looking for the title first and the connection second."
If we bring it back to the very beginning of the conversation, then it's just this checklist exercise of, "Okay, this person fulfills these checkboxes, and that should now be okay for us to live happily ever after." But in reality, that's only one small part of who that person is. Yes, they fulfill all these categories, but do they emotionally, physically, and cognitively actually fulfill the other parts of your needs?
Fernanda: Yes, and you to them.
Pieter Niemann: Yes.
Fernanda: And to go a little bit deeper to add on to everything you're saying—because I 100% agree—we are not always our best selves even in relationships.
Pieter Niemann: No.
Fernanda: I had read a quote a few years ago, something like "relationships are prisms." Like, depending on the angle of the prism that is reflecting upon you, you might see a different version of your partner, and the energy you get from them might be different. So we're always adjusting to each other, and we're bouncing things off of our surfaces at different angles.
Pieter Niemann: Yes.
Fernanda: So it just goes a lot deeper than just checking boxes and having a perfect profile, right?
Pieter Niemann: Yeah. There's a quote—and for the life of me, I'm quickly looking at my book here because I can't remember this quote specifically—but there's a quote by a Brazilian writer, because I have a few Brazilian friends who I had conversations with during the writing of the book, and they led me to this quote. If I'm not mistaken, it's all about "the person becomes the person who you think they are." Okay, I'm going to have to look that up.
Fernanda: Yeah, is it Paulo Coelho by any chance?
Pieter Niemann: I have no idea. It's somewhere in the book.
Fernanda: Okay.
Pieter Niemann: But yes, and it leans heavily into what you're saying: we are dynamic creatures. We are dynamic beings, so you're never the same person. Even if you think about the process of dating, the person who you're dating is most often not the person that you end up in a relationship with.
When you meet somebody for the first time, you put your best foot forward. You make sure to be the better version of yourself, and then you minimize certain things and maximize other things, so you're never the full authentic person who you are. And it's not because you're trying to lie to them often; it's just, right, you want to be chosen. Then down the line, the person slightly changes and you're like, "Huh, okay, that's different." So we change, we're dynamic. We often reflect the world in different ways because of the things that are going on in our lives.
Fernanda: Right. Yeah, that's so deep, and thanks for bringing that quote up. I've heard you say a few times here in the interview that we need to build emotional intimacy and truly get to know a person rather than just expecting them to check the boxes primarily. How would you tell a dater to build emotional intimacy with someone new without rushing it, or without holding back so much that we never let anyone in?
Pieter Niemann: Two things I would say: authenticity. If you are able to know yourself to a point where you're comfortable with who you are, to be authentic in who you are, that is a huge plus point. And not everybody can do that. Life happened to a lot of people, which means that they've been taught to hide and to change who they are because it's safer. But to be as authentic as you can is the first biggest step.
The second thing is participation. If you are meeting a person and you're actually participating in the development of the connection—and this is connection; this doesn't mean that it's romantic or intimate or sexual or whatever, this is just connection—if you're proactive in the actual forming of this connection, then the connection is most likely to result in something.
Unfortunately, not everybody you're meeting is going to be your best friend. Not everybody you're going to meet is going to be your boyfriend or your girlfriend or your husband or your wife. But the more you practice connecting to people, the easier it becomes. The more I practice saying hello to people, the easier it becomes for me to be able to say hello to people.
I have a friend, and I write about that incident in the book under "the Noni effect." She's this amazing person that I met in Cape Town, where she has this rule that when she goes anywhere, she has to walk away with at least one person's contact details and meet up with them later. I was so amazed by her willingness and wanting to connect to people that I spoke to my partner and said, "I'm going to Noni-fy the situation tonight, and I'm going to make sure to walk out with at least one contact detail."
It is networking, yes, but for me, I was learning and I was connecting to people even though it didn't always go anywhere. I was consciously and purposefully trying to connect, and that is the way about it. You can't do more, you can't do less.
Fernanda: Yes, I love this "Noni-fy." I'm going to start using the term "Noni-fy." That's awesome. So I'm curious about the queer perspective. Are there things about dating for queer people that maybe straight people don't realize? Like, are there differences, and would you mind sharing that with me and the audience?
Pieter Niemann: So, I would love to say no, that there isn't actually a difference between queer and heterosexual or different types of connection, because connection is connection. I think it's the practice thereof that changes, so how we perform connection is slightly different.
For instance—which also happens in the straight community—there's the cruising culture, and those things are very gay-specific, but it's just a different way of people connecting to each other. Although cruising isn't about real long-term connection, it's just a short-term interaction. So yes, in the performance of connection, there's a difference, but connection stays the same. We're still human, right?
Fernanda: It's more about the how—how you get there, right? That's a little different. Okay.
Pieter Niemann: Yes. And that's why the book is written from my queer perspective, but it's not just for queer people, because connection is connection.
Fernanda: Yes, no, I totally see that. And I think just from you being here talking to me, every topic we've talked about so far has been very relevant to anyone—definitely not just queer folks, anybody who's looking for connection, right?
Pieter Niemann: Yeah, definitely.
Fernanda: Okay. How does knowing who we are shape the people we choose, and what do we carry in from our past relationships?
Pieter Niemann: Well, we carry everything from ourselves. I think this boils down to the question of if we're ready or not. Because if you are not over a relationship, if you don't deem yourself ready, then maybe you should explore that a bit first before you jump into the next relationship, which a lot of people do.
I've done it myself. I've been in a relationship, I just got out, jumped into the next one, and then suddenly, "Oh, okay, I'm not actually ready for this connection or dynamic."
For me, readiness is mostly about the willingness to actually try. Are you willing to put yourself in a position where you're willing to connect not just with the person, but the potential consequences thereof? Because if I connect to you, I'm not just connecting to you for now. There's the potential that we might develop into something. So am I consciously willing to actually take these steps and actually be there potentially later?
Fernanda: Mhm. Intentionality and matching the energy, kind of—that it takes effort, and it takes presence and wanting to be there.
Pieter Niemann: Yes.
Fernanda: So, does your book include reflective practices, and if so, is there something a listener could try tonight before they open an app or go on a date?
Pieter Niemann: Well, the book is written for the reader to actually ask themselves the questions. I try to present an idea and then have them think about their own life and their own situation, where they can then see, "Okay, am I seeing this like this? Am I doing this? How can I change my ways to be more congruent with myself?"
If I can give anybody a practice that they can try, it's asking themselves: "What is it that I'm needing that I'm going onto these apps at this moment?" Not just asking the question, but actually really thinking about their answer, because we can give the answer easily: "Oh no, well, I'm lonely."
But what does that mean? Do we need to spend more time with our friends, or am I lonely, or am I just taking space for myself? That one honest question gives you so many details if you're able to honestly reflect on that question.
Fernanda: Yeah, it seems like I could apply this to a lot of other things like doomscrolling or browsing social media.
Pieter Niemann: Oh, yeah.
Fernanda: And if you're going on the app just to pass the time and browse, is it a good use of your time? Is it going to be helpful to you? So those are some good questions.
Pieter Niemann: I would even ask if it's a good use of your time, because most often it's going to be no. The bigger question is: why is it so important for you to look for these people at this moment? What emotions are currently stirring within my soul that are making me feel that I need to connect to somebody right now?
Fernanda: Yeah, that's such a thoughtful inquiry. Thanks for sharing that. In the early weeks of dating—which I recognize are fragile, right? They can break up very quickly—what are the signs that someone is emotionally safe and choosing you back?
Pieter Niemann: You see, that becomes a very individualized question. It's very difficult to give a huge generalization, but a person that's safe is not going to pressure. They're not going to force. They're not going to make you question yourself.
If a person is emotionally safe, they're going to allow you to be. There are no strings attached to the connection. It's, "Do you want to hang out tonight? Yes or no?" And that's kind of the end of it. They're not going to play games with you like, "I miss you so much and I haven't seen you all week because you've been busy." It's not going to be any of that.
It's just, "I would like to see you tonight. Want to hang out?" It often feels easy, uncomplicated, unforced. You lack the guilt, because that's what a safe relationship is. A relationship is safe when you are not pressured into sharing, into giving up. You're just allowed to be.
Fernanda: And you're not having to second-guess or wonder, "Do they want to be with me or not?" It's pretty simple, right?
Pieter Niemann: But unfortunately, a lot of people have now been trained by society that those are boring relationships—or unsafe relationships—because the person is not passionately in love. Again, Disney has a big part to play in this, or the movies, because passion is apparently what true love is: the "you complete me," running-to-the-airport scenes.
Fernanda: Yeah.
Pieter Niemann: But is that actually what true love is? Or is true love allowing the person to exist in their space as they are? For me, that is true love—if I am just allowed.
Fernanda: Yes, I love that. Thanks for the reminder. I honestly don't think we can get enough reminders that media can make things unrealistic, especially in the realm of romance, and now let's add social media to it too. It used to be just Disney movies and romantic comedies, but now there's a lot more out there.
Pieter Niemann: Oh, yeah. It's getting more and more difficult to just see what healthy, good, loving connections are.
Fernanda: True. So I'm sure maybe from your friend circles—and I certainly have met a lot of folks like this—if someone feels burnt out about dating and they're feeling hopeless, what would you want them to hear?
Pieter Niemann: Connect to their friends. Connect to their community. If you are feeling burnt out by not finding your partner, are you actually looking for a connection, or are you looking for that title?
For me, it is: connect to your friends, connect to your community. If you don't have one, start creating one. Start living your life. If you stop planning, plans are going to happen. You might even find the person of your dreams by just existing, by living, by being who you want to or are meant to be.
Fernanda: Yes, absolutely. So I'm at my last question. When readers close your book, what do you hope that they feel and do next?
Pieter Niemann: When people close the book, I would love them to take a deep breath and actually just start connecting—start connecting to community, start looking for the way for them to live connectedly. Again, it doesn't have to be romantic or intimate. It's just that they have a community to which they connect, and find one if they don't have one.
Fernanda: Yes, I love it. Thank you so much for sharing your time and your heart with us today. I loved how gently you talked about loneliness and how much courage it takes to keep showing up for love. For everyone listening, you can find Swiping for Something Real—I'm going to add the link in the show notes, and I'll put Pieter's details in the show notes so that you can start following his work.
If today's conversation stirred something in you, I hope you'll take one small step this week. Maybe it means journaling on what you're really looking for, or maybe it's telling someone how you feel instead of waiting for them to guess. If you're in the Charlotte area and you want to meet people in person, come find us at a Filled Cups event. Until next time, keep choosing connection, choosing people who choose you. Thank you.
Connecting individuals through meaningful relationships and valuable resources.
connect
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for valuable insights and event news.
© 2026. Filled Cups.® All Rights Reserved.
Bring FC to your city
INSPIRATION
